There is a metric that every B2B email platform leads with: open rate. It feels intuitive. If 40% of your emails are being opened, you must be doing something right.
You're probably not.
This isn't a minor quibble about measurement accuracy. The open-rate signal is fundamentally broken for most email senders, and building your outreach strategy around it is likely costing you real business.
In September 2021, Apple released iOS 15 and macOS Monterey with a feature called Mail Privacy Protection (MPP). When enabled — and it is enabled by default for most Apple Mail users — MPP downloads your email's entire content, including tracking pixels, through Apple's proxy servers before the recipient ever opens the message.
From a tracking pixel's perspective, every single Apple Mail user "opened" your email the moment it was delivered to their inbox. Whether they actually read it, deleted it without looking, or are currently on holiday — irrelevant. The pixel fired. The open was logged.
Apple Mail accounts for approximately 58% of all email client market share as of 2025, according to data aggregated across major email service providers. That means more than half of every "open" your platform reports may be coming from an Apple server farm somewhere in California, not from a real buyer considering your product.
Let's make this concrete. Suppose you send 500 emails and your platform reports a 40% open rate. That's 200 "opens."
If 58% of your contacts use Apple Mail, roughly 290 of those 500 emails triggered MPP's pre-loading — meaning 290 "opens" arrived before a human ever looked at your subject line. Your "200 opens" likely includes a significant number of phantom opens baked into that 40%.
The actual number of humans who read your email could be far lower. You have no way of knowing.
A 40% open rate with zero replies tells you almost nothing about whether your outreach is working.
A reply cannot be faked by a proxy server.
When a buyer at a wholesale boutique takes time out of their day to write back — even to say "not interested" — you know a real human read your email. They processed it. They took action. That is unambiguous signal.
More importantly, Gmail's deliverability algorithm specifically rewards reply behavior. Google's spam systems are designed to distinguish between emails that generate conversation and emails that generate deletions. A consistent pattern of recipients replying to your messages teaches Gmail that your emails belong in primary inboxes, not promotions tabs, and certainly not spam.
This isn't speculation. Google has published guidance that sender reputation is built on engagement signals. Reply-generating email is the highest-quality engagement signal available.
In cold B2B email outreach, a 2–3% reply rate is genuinely excellent performance. For context:
Now compare that to the 40% open rate scenario above. If those opens produced zero replies, zero conversations, zero orders — what was the 40% actually worth?
The answer is: nothing, except false confidence and a growing list of contacts who are now slightly more likely to mark your next email as spam.
If reply rate is the metric, everything about how you write outreach emails changes.
Be specific. Generic emails that could have been sent to anyone are deleted without a second thought. An email that references the recipient's company, their likely product category, or their geographic market signals that you've thought about them as a real business.
Be brief. Research from multiple email marketing studies in 2025–2026 consistently shows that emails between 50 and 125 words generate approximately 50% higher reply rates than longer messages. Your outreach email is not a product brochure. It's an opening line in a conversation.
Ask one specific question or make one specific ask. "Let me know if you'd like to explore this" generates fewer replies than "Would Tuesday or Wednesday work for a quick 5-minute call?" The more specific your ask, the easier it is for the recipient to respond.
Plain text outperforms HTML for cold outreach. Designed HTML emails look like marketing. Plain text emails look like they came from a real person. For cold B2B outreach — especially in wholesale where relationships drive everything — looking like a real person is a significant deliverability and response advantage.
Apple has shown no signs of reversing MPP. If anything, privacy features have become a core part of Apple's brand differentiation. Gmail and other providers are watching. There is a plausible scenario where proxy-based email pre-loading becomes the norm across major email clients over the next few years.
The platforms that help you track inflated open rates are selling you a metric that is becoming less meaningful every quarter. The platforms that teach you to optimize for replies are building on a signal that will remain reliable regardless of what email clients do next.
If you're running B2B email outreach — whether for wholesale, distribution, or direct-to-retail sales — here's what to prioritize:
The goal isn't a high open rate. The goal is a buyer writing back asking for your line sheet.
Those two things are not the same, and optimizing for the wrong one is an expensive mistake.
LeadWithEmail sends reply-optimized emails from your own Gmail — and shows only genuine reply metrics, not inflated open counts.
Start 7-day free trial →